The picture above is typical of a Protestant Church you could see anywhere in a small town in the Midwest. A lot of those churches now exist “on the edge“. COVID is the latest of the trials that have put a real hurt on them. It was real easy for people not going to church, to forget about giving to that church. I’ve also heard reports of churches that simply lost 30% or so of their parishioners during that time. I don’t know how a “virus” did it, but it did, without question.
I visited my childhood church recently and it was quite an eyeopener. Attendance was low. The people who were there were all older. There were no kids. The “interim pastor” was now starting their second year. Little indications about maintenance and upkeep were evident. If 1968 was a measurement of the ‘Best of Times’ ( a ’10’), these were clearly the worst of times ( a ‘2’). Then I started to wonder, “Why was that?” What was different now?
In 1968 they had a pastor at the top of his game. The Sunday school was full in all grades. The church had lots of activities throughout the week and a Youth Group. All that in the “old”, original building. None of that exists today. Including the building. They had even gotten rid of the ‘newer’ education building where Sunday school was held and the offices were.
In the early 80’s they had decided they needed a new building. Unknown to them it was at the start of the “farm crisis”. A lot of their big money people had been farmers. The transition that took place in farming in the ensuing years was very damaging I believe. Land values skyrocketed (for those who survived). When a couple retired they no longer sold the farm to the next generation of farmers. It stayed in the family. It was literally worth millions.
The farmers today that surround the community are rarely the landowners, the ones with the big money. They’re renters. And while they’re doing okay, they’re not rolling in the big bucks. If its a dairy, egg, poultry or pork situation, its very likely the hands are illegals who don’t care one wit about the community. In fact the manager of the farm might live in Des Moines. There’s no sense of community in that.
Another hit was a double whammy with the local schools in the late 60’s. Instead of each town having its own junior high and high school (and all those good jobs), with school consolidation, only every 3rd or 4th town had “the high school”. The other hit that happened were with the associated jobs like bus driver and food services. Instead of being district employees with good pay and benefits, they were now contract employees of people who put in the lowest bid.
Then in the 70’s when the new EPA rules made lots of industry nearly impossible, outsourcing of good jobs to Mexico and China went through the roof. Those 3 areas: farming, schools, and manufacturing just decimated the churches. Each small town would have some sort of decent job, a jerky plant, a spice plant, something that paid a decent wage.
I just realized something else. I had been reading a national columnist a few years back and they had made a simple observation about returning vets after WW II. A lot of them opened up a service station! We had 3. A Sinclair, a Phillips 66 and a DX. Once again the EPA destroyed an entire class of family owned service stations. Those small time operators couldn’t withstand changing fuel tanks every few years at the EPA’s whim for a quarter of a million dollars.
Regulation forced those guys out. Now all they got is a Casey’s. And the manager of that Casey’s doesn’t make anywhere near what the owner of that service station did. The owner that paid to have his name on the back of the local little league team. And sponsored the girl’s basketball team to State. The guy who paid for the local Boy Scout Toop’s uniforms.
You combine the economic hits on the small towns, with the societal (internet, cable TV), all these influences working against the church, its no wonder they’re hurting. Wages for the average worker just have not kept up. Its a lot easier to be respectable making $25 bucks an hour, then it is at $7.50. Another thing was about 1963 a court case removed “prayer from schools”. That seems like a small thing now, but I don’t think it was at the time.
And regrettably, the money a lot of us give to ‘the church’, is from the money that’s left after everything else has been paid. The churches didn’t help themselves either. Losing a pastor to a morality failing. Not finding a way to accommodate a special needs girl wanting to be in the church choir. Little things that cause hurts and lost members.
What the small town church’s do have going for them is they own the land they’re on and they are tax exempt from property taxes. Regrettably another really big plus they would have had, but none have today, is the parsonage. Those went by the wayside many decades ago. Pastor’s in the rich times had to have bigger and better homes. Now in the lean times a parsonage would have made a smaller income go a lot further.
They knew what they were doing in the old days. We think we’re a lot smarter then we actually are.
[What gives me hope though was observing another church in that town when I drove through Sunday morning. It had a service! I saw people going in! I had thought it was on the National Registrar of Historic Places and was no longer a functioning church, but it was. In a lot of small towns the church closest to teetering on the edge, the one I’m talking about, is a Congregationalist Church. I don’t know why, I don’t know all the backstory on it, but it is something I’ve observed. So I realized at the end of this piece, if they can do it, my old church should be able to do it too!]